Resource conflict analysis

Description

Predicts interference between concurrent tasks by scoring their combined demand and their overlap on shared resources, before any user testing.

Resource conflict analysis turns multiple resource theory into a quantitative prediction. Each task receives a demand score, and each pair of tasks receives a conflict score based on how many resource dimensions they share (modality, code, stage, visual channel). Total interference is the sum of demand scores plus weighted conflict scores. Wickens's model and W/INDEX use a conflict matrix with values from 0 (no shared resources) to 1 (all shared). The analysis compares candidate designs, for instance whether an alert should be visual text, an icon, a tone or speech. It is analytical, so it can be done early, but results should be validated with dual-task or simulator studies. Rigour comes from transparent coding and sensitivity analysis on uncertain weights.

Attributes

Loss type
Siloed
Stage
Design
Effort
Days

Steps

  1. Decompose the scenario into concurrent task pairs or time segments.
  2. Assign each task a demand score (for example 0 for automatic, 1 for easy, 2 for difficult).
  3. Code each task's resource profile and compute a conflict value for each pair from a conflict matrix (0 to 1, higher with more shared dimensions).
  4. Compute total interference for each design alternative and rank them.
  5. Run sensitivity analysis by varying uncertain demand and conflict weights by plus or minus 25%.
  6. Validate the top-ranked design with a dual-task test or simulator study.

Sources

  • Salvendy, G. (ed.), Handbook of Human Factors and Ergonomics
  • Gopinath, V., Methods Atlas
  • Handbook of Human Factors & Ergonomics (Salvendy)
  • Methods Atlas (Gopinath)
  • The Inquiry Series, Ch 12 — Multiple Resource Theory — The Bandwidth of the Human

Also known as

  • Multiple resource conflict analysis
  • Time-sharing interference prediction
  • Workload conflict matrix

Categories

  • Accessibility
  • Human Factors & Error