Requisite Imagination Conceptual Design Review

Description

A reflective design-stage review that walks a planned design through nine considerations, from task and organisation to past failures and constraints, to foresee what could go wrong.

Requisite imagination is the capacity to anticipate how a design might fail before it is built. Adamski and Westrum turn it into a review of nine components that can be taken in any order: the task and design intent; the organisation (culture, resources, decision-makers, customers and users); the alignment of designers' and users' worlds across expertise levels; the operational domain and its stressors; past failures and potential human error; information needs and filtering; procedures, flexibility and training; conventions, which are reviewed and challenged; and constraints. A checklist accompanies it. The authors stress that it is reflective rather than a fixed sequence, so its rigour comes from systematically covering every component and from bringing in historical failure cases, not from scoring. It differs from a pre-mortem in being organised around design dimensions rather than an imagined failed outcome.

Attributes

Loss type
Siloed
Effort
Days

Steps

  1. Clarify the task the design supports and the designers' intent.
  2. Consider the organisation: culture, resources, decision-makers, customers and users.
  3. Compare the designers' world with users' worlds at different expertise levels and surface hidden assumptions.
  4. Describe the operational domain and its stressors, then survey past failures in similar systems and potential human errors.
  5. Review information needs and filtering, procedures, flexibility and training.
  6. Challenge the conventions the design relies on and review constraints.
  7. Record each foreseeable failure mode with a proposed design change and an owner.

Sources

  • Handbook of Cognitive Task Design (Hollnagel, 2003)

Also known as

  • Requisite imagination
  • Requisite imagination: conceptual design review

Categories

  • Accessibility
  • Human Factors & Error