Description
Collect a memory report soon after an event, then ask the same questions after delays and score later reports against the baseline for consistency, detail and confidence.
Bartlett (1932) asked people to reproduce the story 'The War of the Ghosts' at increasing intervals and found it shortened and reshaped to fit their own culture. The modern consistency-scoring version collects a baseline report as soon as possible after an event, then repeats the same questions later. Neisser and Harsch (1992) questioned students the day after the Challenger explosion and again 2.5-3 years later; reports of first hearing the news on TV rose from 21 to 45 per cent and many accounts were entirely different. Talarico and Rubin (2003) compared 9/11 memories with an everyday event retested at 1, 6 or 32 weeks: detail fell equally, but vividness and confidence stayed high only for 9/11. The central lesson is that confidence and vividness do not indicate accuracy. For UX it calibrates how much to trust retrospective accounts in interviews and surveys.
Attributes
- Discipline
- Cognitive Psychology & Perception
- Loss type
- Unmigrated
- Stage
- Discovery, Post-launch
- Data
- Mixed
- Effort
- Months
Steps
- Collect a structured baseline report as soon as possible after the event, ideally within 24 hours.
- Include a comparison event (for example an everyday session) cued with a two- or three-word label.
- Retest the same participants with identical questions at planned delays, for example 1, 6 and 32 weeks, assigning participants to one delay to avoid rehearsal effects.
- Collect ratings of vividness and confidence alongside the content.
- Score each later report against the baseline for consistency and number of details.
- Compare consistency with confidence ratings to quantify the gap between belief and accuracy.
Sources
- Cognitive Psychology (Goldstein, 2019)
- The Mind (Goldstein, 2020)
- Cognitive Psychology (Sternberg & Sternberg, 2012)
Also known as
- Repeated recall
- Bartlett's repeated reproduction
- Bartlett's "War of the Ghosts" reproduction
- Flashbulb memory consistency test
- Test-retest memory consistency
Categories
- User Research
- Cognitive Psychology & Perception