Reading-Time Paradigms

Description

Readers reveal text segment by segment or press when they understand, and logged times per region locate exactly where comprehension slows.

In self-paced reading, text is revealed one word or phrase at a time with each key press (or, in Zwaan and Taylor's variant, each small knob turn), and the latency for each region is logged; garden-path sentences slow at the point of reanalysis, and mismatches with a previously seen picture slow reading by about 50 ms. In the given-new paradigm, participants see sentence pairs and press as soon as they understand the second; comprehension is faster when its given information was stated in the first sentence than when it must be inferred, which tests the given-new contract between writer and reader. The rigour comes from matched conditions differing only in the critical region, many items and participants, comprehension questions to check reading, and comparison of region times rather than whole-text times. For UX, the paradigms can locate where policies, error messages or AI answers make readers stall.

Attributes

Loss type
Unmigrated
Effort
Weeks

Steps

  1. Write matched text versions that differ only in a critical region, such as two wordings of a fee clause or error message.
  2. Divide each text into regions with the critical region at a known position.
  3. Reveal one region per key press, or show sentence pairs and record when the participant signals understanding, logging each latency.
  4. Add comprehension questions after a proportion of items to check genuine reading.
  5. Use enough items and participants (typically dozens of each) and counterbalance versions across participants.
  6. Compare region reading times across conditions with mixed-effects models, treating participants and items as random effects.

Sources

  • Louder Than Words (Bergen, 2012)
  • Cognitive Psychology (Goldstein, 2019)

Also known as

  • Reading-time paradigms (self-paced reading, given-new comprehension time)
  • Self-paced reading
  • Self-paced reading with region-by-region reading times
  • Moving-window reading
  • Knob-turn reading
  • Region reading-time analysis
  • Given-new comprehension time
  • Text-level reading-time studies

Categories

  • Content
  • Linguistics, Semiotics & Discourse