Description
Testing whether real readers can find and understand content, using cloze tests, comprehension questions and think-aloud reading, with pass thresholds rather than formula scores.
Readability testing measures comprehension directly with target readers, in contrast to readability formulas that only estimate difficulty. Techniques include the cloze test (every fifth or sixth word deleted, readers fill gaps, 60% or more correct indicates adequate comprehension), comprehension questions requiring readers to locate and explain key points, paraphrase tasks, and think-aloud reading. European medicines regulation formalised a rigorous version: 20 participants in rounds of ten, with a criterion that 90% must find each key piece of information and 90% of those must understand it. In UX the method is vestigial: it survives as informal 'does this make sense?' checks, losing the explicit thresholds, the find-versus-understand distinction and the iterative rounds that made it reliable.
Attributes
- Discipline
- Information Architecture & Content
- Loss type
- Vestigial
- Goal
- Evaluate usability
- Stage
- Evaluation
- Data
- Mixed
- Effort
- Days
Steps
- Identify 10-15 key points the content must convey (actions, risks, eligibility, deadlines).
- Write neutral questions for each point that require locating and explaining it, not just recognising wording.
- Test with target readers in rounds of about 10, recording whether each point was found and whether it was understood correctly.
- Optionally run a cloze test on key passages, deleting every fifth word and scoring exact or acceptable answers, with 60% as the comprehension threshold.
- Apply a criterion such as 90% of participants finding and 90% of those understanding each key point; revise content that falls short.
- Retest revised content with a fresh round until all key points meet the criterion.
Sources
- Strategic Content Design
- Taylor, Cloze procedure (Journalism Quarterly, 1953)
- Sless & Wiseman, Writing About Medicines for People (1994)
- Taylor, 'Cloze procedure': A new tool for measuring readability (1953), Journalism Quarterly
- Bormuth, Cloze test readability: Criterion reference scores (1968), Journal of Educational Measurement
Also known as
- Comprehension testing
- Cloze testing
- Content usability testing
- Cloze procedure
- Cloze comprehension test
Categories
- Content
- Information Architecture & Content