Re-Invention Measurement Against Core Elements

Description

Breaks an innovation into elements and measures, for each adopter, how far their implementation departs from the core version, separating harmful loss from useful adaptation.

Re-invention is the degree to which users change an innovation during adoption and implementation; its opposite is fidelity. Diffusion research measures it by first defining the innovation's elements and its core or main-line version, then, for each adopter observed at implementation rather than at stated intent, coding each element as kept, modified, added or dropped. Re-invention is expressed as departure from the core, with core and peripheral elements distinguished, and then related to rate of adoption and sustainability. Findings are consistent: re-invention is common (for example 56% of schools in one network implemented only selected parts), it speeds adoption and raises sustainability, but adopters over-report it and some is mere renaming. The key judgement is whether a change removes a core element that makes the innovation work.

Attributes

Loss type
Unmigrated
Stage
Post-launch
Data
Mixed
Effort
Weeks

Steps

  1. Measure adoption at the implementation stage, not as intention.
  2. Break the innovation into elements and define its core version, with an evidence-based view of which elements are essential.
  3. For each adopter, code each element as kept, modified, added or dropped, verifying self-reports against observation or artefacts.
  4. Compute a departure-from-core score, separating core from peripheral elements and excluding pure renaming.
  5. Relate re-invention to adoption rate, outcomes and sustainability.
  6. Feed commonly changed elements back into design, making useful adaptations official and protecting core elements.

Sources

  • Diffusion of Innovations (Rogers, 2003)

Also known as

  • Measuring re-invention against core elements
  • Fidelity measurement
  • Adaptation-fidelity scoring

Categories

  • Analytics & Behaviour
  • Product Analytics & Strategy