Description
An informal, facilitator-led session where evaluator and participant explore a design together, using tasks as props and pursuing issues as they arise, with no quantitative measures.
Hartson and Pyla separate rigorous empirical evaluation (benchmark tasks, quantitative targets) from quasiempirical methods, which still involve real participants, or an evaluator emulating one, but are informal: no quantitative data, no benchmark tasks, any location and frequent changes of direction. Tasks drawn from scenarios, essential use cases or task models serve as props rather than measurement instruments. The facilitator builds a partnership with the participant, prompts think-aloud, lets them explore and choose some tasks, and freely interrupts to probe reactions, unclear parts, comparisons, suggestions and typical-day use. Notes are the only raw data. Its value is speed and depth of qualitative insight during formative iteration; its weakness is dependence on facilitator skill and the absence of anything to compare across rounds.
Attributes
- Discipline
- Usability & Evaluation
- Loss type
- Renamed
- Stage
- Design, Evaluation
- Data
- Qualitative
- Effort
- Days
Steps
- Prepare representative, frequent and mission-critical tasks plus exploratory questions.
- Assign a facilitator and note-takers; consider two participants together for co-discovery.
- Build rapport and frame the session as a partnership; prompt think-aloud.
- Let the participant explore freely, then use tasks as props, letting them choose some.
- Follow emerging threads: ask about reactions, unclear parts, comparisons, suggestions and how it would fit a typical day.
- Take thorough notes as the only raw data and convert them into a problem and suggestion list straight after.
Sources
- The UX Book (Hartson & Pyla, 2019)
Also known as
- Quasiempirical UX evaluation
- Quasi-empirical evaluation
- Informal exploratory evaluation
Categories
- User Research
- Usability & Evaluation