Description
Models judgements with quantum probability, where asking one question changes the answer to the next, to explain and test order and framing effects in surveys and choices.
Classical probability assumes that a person holds fixed opinions and a question simply reads them out, so the order of questions should not matter. In practice it does: asking about trust before satisfaction gives different answers from the reverse order. Quantum cognition treats a mental state as a set of possibilities that a question resolves, in the way a measurement changes a physical system. That framing makes specific, testable predictions. The best known is the QQ equality: for two yes/no questions asked in both orders to split samples, a particular combination of the order effects should be zero if the quantum account holds. For UX research this offers more than a curiosity. It gives a principled way to decide whether an order effect in a survey is noise, a carry-over bias you should counterbalance away, or a real feature of how people build judgements on the spot, which matters for in-product micro-surveys, onboarding questions and preference elicitation.
Attributes
- Discipline
- Cognitive Psychology & Perception
- Loss type
- Latent
- Stage
- Design, Evaluation
- Data
- Quantitative
- Effort
- Days
Steps
- Pick pairs of judgement questions where order could matter, such as trust and satisfaction, or price fairness and value.
- Randomly assign respondents to answer each pair in one order or the other (A then B, or B then A).
- For yes/no or binarised answers, tabulate the four joint outcomes for each order.
- Compute the order effects and the QQ equality statistic; check whether it is close to zero.
- If order effects exist and satisfy the QQ equality, treat answers as constructed in context: fix a deliberate order that matches the real product moment rather than averaging orders away.
- If order effects break the equality, look for ordinary carry-over or fatigue and counterbalance.
Sources
- Cognitive Modeling: Nine Paradigms (slide deck)
- Busemeyer, J. & Bruza, P., Quantum Models of Cognition and Decision (2012)
Also known as
- Quantum cognition models
- QQ equality test for question-order effects
Categories
- User Research
- Cognitive Psychology & Perception