Quality Criteria Sets for Qualitative and Grounded Theory Research

Description

Choose a named set of quality criteria that fits the study's paradigm, plan how each will be met, and use the same set to appraise the finished work.

Qualitative quality depends on which criteria an audience applies. Strauss and Corbin give seven research-process questions (sampling, categories, indicators, theoretical sampling, hypotheses, discrepancies, choice of core category) and eight grounding criteria for grounded theory. Charmaz judges credibility, originality, resonance and usefulness. Yardley's four characteristics are sensitivity to context, commitment and rigour, transparency and coherence, and impact and importance, with constructivist additions such as reflexivity and negative-case analysis. Whittemore adds explicitness, congruence and vividness. Patton contrasts five sets: traditional scientific, constructivist, artistic and evocative, critical change, and evaluation standards. The procedure is the same across all of them: name the set, design for it, report against it, and anticipate critiques from other sets. It extends the single Lincoln and Guba frame common in UX.

Attributes

Loss type
Siloed
Effort
Hours

Steps

  1. Identify the study's purpose, paradigm and audiences, and which criteria set or sets they will apply.
  2. Select a named set, such as Yardley, Charmaz, Strauss and Corbin, or Whittemore, and state it in the research plan.
  3. For each criterion, write the strategy that will meet it (audit trail, negative cases, reflexive memo, member responses, thick description).
  4. Apply the strategies during fieldwork and analysis, keeping memos as evidence.
  5. Appraise the finished report against each criterion, noting and justifying departures.
  6. Anticipate how audiences using other criteria sets will critique the work and address this in the report.

Sources

  • Basics of Qualitative Research (Strauss & Corbin, 1998)
  • Constructing Grounded Theory (Charmaz, 2006)
  • HCI Encyclopedia (Soegaard & Dam, 2014)
  • Qualitative Research & Evaluation Methods (Patton, 2002)
  • Research Design (Leavy, 2017)
  • Grounded Theory Research (Corbin & Strauss, 1990)

Also known as

  • Strauss and Corbin criteria for evaluating grounded theory research
  • Charmaz's evaluation criteria
  • Credibility, originality, resonance, usefulness
  • Yardley criteria
  • Yardley's quality criteria for qualitative research
  • Patton's quality criteria frameworks
  • Whittemore criteria
  • Qualitative and arts-based evaluation criteria

Categories

  • Research Operations
  • Research Design & Rigor