Description
A set of topics and questions addressed to the researcher, each paired with likely sources of evidence, that is carried in the head to guide conversational fieldwork instead of a scripted interview guide.
Yin separates a protocol from an instrument. An instrument scripts the spoken questions or tasks a participant receives; a protocol states the topics and questions the researcher must answer through the whole line of inquiry. Protocol questions are written to the fieldworker (for example 'Ask about how long R has lived here, and why'), and each is accompanied by the sources of evidence that might answer it: interviews, documents, observation. In the field the researcher does not read from it. The protocol is internalised as a mental framework, like a doctor's clinical line of questioning or a detective's working hypotheses, and spoken questions are composed on the spot in natural conversation. Yin gives three benefits: it keeps the original questions in view, it points to chances to seek contrary as well as supporting evidence, and it helps evidence converge across sources. When something unexpected turns up, the protocol is paused and revised. In multi-site work the same protocol supports parallel data collection, with the fieldworker composing a written answer to each question per site. For UX, it is an alternative to the scripted discussion guide when studying workplaces, services or organisations through mixed sources.
Attributes
- Discipline
- Research Design & Rigor
- Loss type
- Siloed
- Stage
- Discovery
- Data
- Qualitative
- Effort
- Days
Steps
- Group the study's research questions into topics covering the full line of inquiry
- Write each protocol question in the voice of the researcher, not as words to be spoken to a participant
- Next to each question, list the anticipated sources of evidence: who to talk to, which documents, what to observe
- Add operational definitions for key terms and distinguish observed events from reported ones
- Study the protocol until it can be carried in the head; do not read from it during fieldwork
- In the field, compose spoken questions on the spot and seek contrary as well as supporting evidence
- After each site or session, write an answer to each protocol question citing the evidence, and revise the protocol if discoveries require it
Sources
- Yin, R., Qualitative Research from Start to Finish, 2nd ed. (2016)
Also known as
- Field protocol
- Line-of-inquiry protocol
- Protocol, not instrument
- Researcher-directed protocol questions
Categories
- Research Operations
- Research Design & Rigor