Provocative Scenarios and Extreme Characters

Description

Fictional or exaggerated scenarios and characters, such as Scrooge meeting a smart meter, used to provoke design teams into discussing social and cultural consequences of a concept.

These techniques treat scenarios as containers of ideas and tools for dialogue rather than distillations of fact. Pastiche scenarios place well-known fictional characters in front of a proposed technology; because readers already know how Scrooge or Bart Simpson thinks, they can imagine responses that a bland persona would never prompt. Caricature scenarios exaggerate a design's benefits and its problems so far that both enthusiasts and sceptics are pushed to question their positions, making key design points more salient. Extreme characters are invented users with exaggerated emotional attitudes (a drug dealer's phone, a pope's diary) that open aesthetic and cultural possibilities. All three deliberately depart from the factual scenarios of scenario-based design, and are best used for exploring the social, ethical and cultural issues an innovation raises.

Attributes

Loss type
Siloed
Stage
Discovery, Design
Effort
Hours

Steps

  1. State the technology concept and the social or cultural questions you want to open up.
  2. Choose two to four devices: familiar fictional characters (pastiche), exaggerated best and worst cases (caricature), or invented users with extreme emotional attitudes.
  3. Write short scenarios in which each character meets and uses the concept, staying true to the character's known personality.
  4. Write a paired optimistic and pessimistic caricature of the same use.
  5. Read the scenarios aloud in a team or stakeholder session and discuss how each character responds and what issues surface.
  6. Record the issues raised and turn them into design questions or requirements to investigate.

Sources

  • Experience-Centered Design (Wright & McCarthy, 2010)

Also known as

  • Pastiche scenarios
  • Caricature scenarios
  • Extreme characters
  • Fiction-based scenarios

Categories

  • Design
  • Design & Product Practice