Description
Build prototypes of an existing product at several fidelities, run identical trials on each and on the real product, and see which fidelity reproduces real-product results.
Prototype testing assumes the prototype behaves like the eventual product. This study tests that assumption by using an existing product as a datum. Gill and colleagues took the Equinox phone and built a high-fidelity prototype (real mouldings plus interactive electronics and a Flash interface), a low-fidelity foam 'sketch' prototype, and a touchscreen-only software prototype, then ran identical user trials on all and on the real phone. Tangible prototypes behaved like the real phone while the software-only one did not; a picture-on-block version failed because button edges could not be felt. The low-fidelity tangible prototype took about 80 per cent less build time yet matched the real phone better than software. The result is evidence-based guidance on which fidelity dimensions matter for a product class.
Attributes
- Discipline
- Research Design & Rigor
- Loss type
- Latent
- Stage
- Design, Evaluation
- Data
- Quantitative
- Effort
- Weeks
Steps
- Choose an existing product, similar to the one being designed, as the datum.
- Build prototypes that vary physical and visual fidelity independently (for example foam with real buttons, screen-only, full mock-up).
- Run identical tasks and measures with comparable participants on each prototype and the real product.
- Compare each prototype's results (errors, times, ratings) with the real product's.
- Derive fidelity guidance, such as medium visual with high physical fidelity, for future prototyping.
Sources
- Touch IT (Dix et al., 2022)
Also known as
- Prototype fidelity validation against a real product (Equinox study)
- Equinox study
- Physical fidelity study
Categories
- Research Operations
- Research Design & Rigor