Projective Techniques

Description

Indirect prompts (animal boards, sentence stems, personification, picture stories, word association) let people project attitudes onto a frame, surfacing associations they would not state directly.

Projective techniques ask people to respond to an ambiguous or indirect frame instead of a direct question, on the premise that attitudes, motives and feelings are partly outside awareness or socially awkward to state. Formats include sentence completion ('using the app is...'), personification ('if this website were a person, who would it be?'), analogy and fantasy questions, picture storytelling (the TAT asks for a story about each ambiguous picture), word association, and boards of locally meaningful animals matched to products or institutions. Comparative variants test brand fit: participants personify the organisation and then the product, or build one collage for the brand and another after using the product, and mismatches point at the product parts responsible. Rigour depends on locally piloted stimuli, writing answers before discussion, a coding scheme with trained coders and inter-rater checks, and treating results as prompts for probing rather than diagnoses.

Attributes

Loss type
Vestigial
Effort
Days

Steps

  1. Choose one or two formats that fit the question: sentence stems, personification, animal or picture board, picture stories or word association.
  2. Prepare stimuli and pilot them locally, checking what images or animals mean in the participants' culture.
  3. Write stems or prompts covering the domain and, indirectly, the product (for example 'when my routine is interrupted, I feel...', 'to me the app means...').
  4. Have each person answer individually, ideally in writing, before any group discussion.
  5. Probe the qualities, images and words that come up: why that animal, that person, that ending.
  6. Code responses with a predefined scheme (emotions, values, motive imagery, tone) using two coders and an agreement check.
  7. For brand fit, run the same projective question for the brand and the product and locate the causes of mismatches.
  8. Look for associations repeated across participants or groups and validate them with other methods.

Sources

  • Understanding Your Users (Baxter et al., 2015)
  • Emotionally Intelligent Design (Pavliscak, 2018)
  • The Psychology Book (Collin et al., 2012)
  • The Persona Lifecycle (Pruitt & Adlin, 2006)
  • Research Methodology in Behavioural Sciences (Mangal & Mangal, 2013)
  • Funerals Market Study: Qualitative Research Report (Research Works Limited, 2018)
  • Designing for Emotion (Walter, 2011)
  • MIT Psychology (Stangor, 2012)

Also known as

  • Projective techniques (picture/animal boards, sentence completion, TAT, word association, brand personification)
  • Animal picture board
  • Animal association board
  • Projective animal mapping
  • Projective question types for focus groups
  • Krueger question types
  • Sentence completion
  • Sentence completion for emotions and values
  • Projective sentence stems
  • Personification
  • Brand personification
  • Fantasy questions
  • Analogy questions
  • Projective picture storytelling
  • Thematic Apperception Test
  • TAT
  • Picture story exercise
  • Word association test
  • Brand versus product projective comparison
  • Family of brands
  • Photo sort

Categories

  • User Research
  • Interviewing & Elicitation