Product Accident Scenario Analysis (Hazard Patterns)

Description

Group past product accidents into a few hazard patterns covering victim, product, environment and task, then interview new cases about each stage of the task leading to injury.

Most accident classifications cover person, equipment and environment. Drury and Brill add the task, seeking the mismatch between task demands and the capacity of the body subsystem involved. Archival accident reports are sorted into hazard patterns (scenarios), each describing victim, product, environment and task; a pattern set is useful if no more than six patterns cover more than 90% of in-depth cases. The patterns then shape an interview questionnaire for new incidents, recording victim, environment and product details and task performance at four moments: the intended action, the point where it could not be completed as intended, any new or corrective action, and the injury. Demand is judged against capacity at each stage. It is more descriptive than a case-crossover design but better at revealing human factors causes.

Attributes

Loss type
Siloed
Data
Mixed
Effort
Weeks

Steps

  1. Collect in-depth archival accident or incident reports for the product class.
  2. Classify them into hazard patterns describing victim, product, environment and task, aiming for six or fewer patterns covering over 90% of cases.
  3. Build an interview questionnaire from the patterns.
  4. For each new accident, record victim data (age, body part), environment (indoor or outdoor, lighting) and product data (type, shape, weight).
  5. Reconstruct the task at four stages: intended action, failure to complete, corrective action, injury.
  6. Judge task demands against human capacity at each stage and derive design countermeasures for each pattern.

Sources

  • Handbook of Human Factors and Ergonomics (Salvendy & Karwowski, 2021)

Also known as

  • Drury and Brill scenario analysis
  • Hazard pattern analysis
  • Scenario analysis of product accidents

Categories

  • Accessibility
  • Human Factors & Error