Process Tracing

Description

Tests causal explanations within a single case by examining whether the predicted sequence of intermediate steps and evidence is present, using formal evidential tests.

Process tracing examines the causal chain linking a cause to an outcome within a case, asking what observable implications each step of a hypothesised mechanism would leave. Van Evera classified evidential tests by necessity and sufficiency: straw-in-the-wind (weak), hoop (necessary: failing eliminates the hypothesis), smoking gun (sufficient: passing strongly confirms) and doubly decisive. Bayesian process tracing formalises updating. In UX, single cases are common: one enterprise customer's failed rollout, one user's journey to churn, one incident. Process tracing turns case narratives into disciplined causal inference, with rival hypotheses tested against specific evidence.

Attributes

Loss type
Unmigrated
Stage
Post-launch
Effort
Weeks

Steps

  1. Define the outcome and candidate causal explanations, including rivals.
  2. For each explanation, specify the mechanism as a sequence of steps and the evidence each step should leave.
  3. Classify predicted evidence as hoop, smoking-gun, straw-in-the-wind or doubly decisive tests.
  4. Collect evidence: logs, documents, emails, interviews, timelines, with attention to source reliability.
  5. Evaluate each hypothesis against the tests, eliminating those that fail hoop tests.
  6. Write a causal narrative with the evidence chain, and state remaining uncertainty.

Sources

  • George & Bennett, Case Studies and Theory Development in the Social Sciences (2005)
  • Van Evera, Guide to Methods for Students of Political Science (1997)
  • Beach & Pedersen, Process-Tracing Methods: Foundations and Guidelines (2013)
  • Collier, Understanding process tracing (2011), PS: Political Science & Politics

Also known as

  • Causal process tracing
  • Within-case causal inference
  • Van Evera's tests

Categories

  • User Research
  • Qualitative Analysis & Synthesis