Description
Give groups the same problem in structurally identical but differently presented versions, then compare solution time and hints to isolate the effect of representation.
Isomorphs share the same underlying structure and solution but differ in presentation. Because the logic is constant, differences in performance can be attributed to representation alone. Kaplan and Simon (1990) presented the mutilated checkerboard problem (can 31 dominoes cover a board with two opposite corners removed?) blank, coloured, labelled 'black' and 'pink', or 'bread' and 'butter'. The bread-and-butter group, whose labels most stressed that neighbouring squares differ, solved it twice as fast and needed about 1 hint against 3.14 for the blank group. Think-aloud protocols revealed the moment the representation changed. Classic isomorph sets include Tower of Hanoi variants and river-crossing problems such as hobbits and orcs. In UX the method directly tests whether a visualisation, metaphor or label makes a task easier.
Attributes
- Discipline
- Cognitive Psychology & Perception
- Loss type
- Unmigrated
- Stage
- Design, Evaluation
- Data
- Mixed
- Effort
- Days
Steps
- Define the task and verify formally that all versions are true isomorphs with the same solution path.
- Create versions that differ only in presentation (labels, colours, metaphor, visual layout).
- Randomly assign participants to versions, typically 10-20 per version.
- Give hints by a fixed rule, for example after set intervals without progress, and log each hint.
- Collect think-aloud protocols to identify when and how the representation shifts.
- Compare solution time, success rate and hints across versions, and relate differences to protocol evidence.
Sources
- Cognitive Psychology (Goldstein, 2019)
- Cognitive Psychology (Sternberg & Sternberg, 2012)
Also known as
- Isomorphic problem versions
- Problem representation effect
- Mutilated checkerboard paradigm
- Tower of Hanoi isomorphs
- Hobbits and orcs problem
Categories
- User Research
- Cognitive Psychology & Perception