Problem Identification Picture Cards (PIPC)

Description

Children drop emotion picture cards into a box whenever they feel that emotion while using a product, giving non-verbal, time-located reports of problems and fun.

Young children rarely sustain think-aloud. PIPC gives them a non-verbal channel: a set of picture cards, each showing an emotion that maps to a category of usability problem or fun issue, and a box. While playing, the child places a card in the box each time they experience the shown emotion. Card placements, aligned with the session recording, locate both problems and positive moments in time and classify them. In a study with children aged five and six, children explicitly expressed more problems with the cards than in think-aloud sessions. Bekker notes that each adaptation for children can add its own challenges, so the cards must be explained carefully and practised before tasks begin.

Attributes

Loss type
Siloed
Stage
Evaluation
Effort
Days

Steps

  1. Prepare picture cards whose emotions map to problem and fun categories, and a box.
  2. Explain each card to the child and practise placing cards on a warm-up activity.
  3. Video-record the session so card placements can be time-aligned.
  4. While the child uses the product, they place a card in the box each time they feel the shown emotion.
  5. Align each placement with the recording and identify the cause.
  6. Classify by card category into problems and fun issues and compile a list.

Sources

  • HCI Encyclopedia (Soegaard & Dam, 2014)

Also known as

  • Problem identification picture cards method
  • Picture cards method

Categories

  • User Research
  • Usability & Evaluation