Description
Linked exercises for choosing and structuring a problem: laddering it to a sweet spot, pitching it to test passion and support, and breaking it into five subproblems.
Iyengar argues that choosing the problem is the step people spend least time on and should spend most. Step Analysis rewrites a problem as an open 'how' question with no embedded solution, places it mid-chart and restates it two levels wider and two narrower to find where motivation and feasibility peak; in groups each person charts alone before pooling. The Passion Test has the person describe the problem to around 25 people and judge whether their excitement grows; the classroom Innovation Marketplace scales this to rotating trios, before-and-after passion ratings (1-7), revised statements and play-money investments in others' problems (she reports about 35 per cent revise their pitch). Subproblem breakdown lists every subproblem question, groups and cuts repeatedly to about five, checks with experts, users and outsiders, parks solutions in a 'sparking lot', and applies the Eighty Percent Test: would solving all of them solve at least 80 per cent of the problem?
Attributes
- Discipline
- Design & Product Practice
- Loss type
- Siloed
- Data
- Qualitative
- Effort
- Days
Steps
- Write the problem in under three sentences, then as an open 'how' question without an embedded solution, moving numeric targets to implementation.
- Step analysis: place it mid-chart, restate it two levels wider and two narrower, and choose the tier where motivation is highest and the problem still solvable; in groups chart individually, then pool.
- Passion test: pitch the problem in under a minute to many people (rotating trios in a group), rating passion 1-7 before and after and recording revisions.
- In a group marketplace, have each person invest three unequal play-money amounts in others' problems and tally support.
- Subproblem breakdown: list every subproblem question, then group and cut repeatedly, from memory, until about five remain.
- Check the breakdown with experts, users and outsiders, parking solution ideas in a sparking lot, and revise at least once.
- Apply the Eighty Percent Test and carry the subproblems forward as rows of a Choice Map.
Sources
- Think Bigger (Iyengar, 2023)
Also known as
- Step Analysis
- Step Up / Step Down chart
- Problem laddering up and down
- Personal sweet spot
- Innovation Marketplace
- Passion Test
- Idea-Working
- Subproblem breakdown
- Eighty Percent Test
- Sparking lot
- Choice Map subproblems
Categories
- Design
- Design & Product Practice