Problem Discovery, Selection and Solution Validation Cycle

Description

A three-phase planning round in which a team discovers candidate problems, selects a portfolio and validates its chosen solution cheaply before building.

Larson frames product planning, for an engineering lead covering for a missing product manager, as an iterative elimination tournament: each round has problem discovery, problem selection and solution validation, and doing all three well earns another round with more scope. Discovery populates the problem space from users' pain (broad surveys plus deep interviews across segments), users' purpose, benchmarks against similar and very different companies, cohorts hidden in top-level distributions, competitive advantages and moats, and compounding leverage. Selection narrows to a portfolio by asking what is needed to survive this round and the next, what would win, how the choice changes over six-month, two-year and five-year horizons, industry trends, rough return on investment and learning experiments. Validation de-risks the approach: write the customer launch letter, find prior art through trusted people, recruit reference users, run cheap experiments and test switching costs.

Attributes

Loss type
Siloed
Data
Mixed
Effort
Weeks

Steps

  1. Discovery: list candidate problems from users' pain (surveys plus interviews across segments), users' purpose, benchmarks, hidden cohorts, competitive advantages, moats and compounding leverage.
  2. Selection: filter to a problem portfolio by survival this round and next, what would win a round, six-month, two-year and five-year horizons, industry trends, rough return on investment and experiments that ease future selection.
  3. Validation: write the customer launch letter for the chosen solution.
  4. Find prior art through people you trust rather than conference talks.
  5. Recruit reference users willing to go first; if none can be found, doubt the project.
  6. Run the cheapest experiment that could invalidate the approach, including whether users would pay the switching cost.
  7. Repeat the round with the larger scope earned.

Sources

  • An Elegant Puzzle (Larson, 2019)

Also known as

  • Problem discovery, problem selection and solution validation (iterative elimination tournament)
  • Iterative elimination tournament

Categories

  • Design
  • Design & Product Practice