Presentation models (PM/PIM/PMR)

Description

Describe each screen or mode as widget triples, link screens in a navigation state model, map behaviours to specified functions, and check for gaps, deadlocks and refinement violations.

Presentation models give informal design artefacts such as prototypes and storyboards a formal meaning without replacing them. Each window, dialogue or mode becomes a presentation model listing every widget as a triple of name, category and behaviours; sensors, speech and gestures count as widgets. Behaviours are split into interactive behaviours (navigation and presentation) and system behaviours (functionality). A presentation interaction model is a state machine with one state per window or mode, used to check reachability, deadlocks and navigation length. A presentation model relation maps system behaviours to operations in a formal specification, exposing interface functions the specification lacks and specified functions with no widget. Alternative designs are compared by refinement: system behaviours must be equal and interactive behaviours of the new design must include the old.

Attributes

Loss type
Siloed
Effort
Weeks

Steps

  1. Collect the design artefacts: prototypes, storyboards and scenarios.
  2. Write one presentation model per window, dialogue or mode, with a triple per widget (name, category, behaviours).
  3. Classify each behaviour as interactive (navigation, presentation) or system (functionality).
  4. Build the presentation interaction model with one state per presentation model; check reachability, deadlocks and navigation sequence length.
  5. Build the presentation model relation mapping each system behaviour to a specified operation; flag unmapped behaviours and specified operations with no widget.
  6. Compare alternative or restricted designs for refinement: equal system behaviours, and a superset of interactive behaviours.
  7. Optionally combine the models into one formal model and check safety properties with a model checker.

Sources

  • The Handbook of Formal Methods in HCI (Weyers et al., 2017)

Also known as

  • Presentation model analysis
  • PM/PIM/PMR
  • Presentation interaction models
  • Presentation model relation
  • Bowen and Reeves presentation models
  • Contractual utility refinement of UI designs

Categories

  • Accessibility
  • Human Factors & Error