Description
For each subproblem, collect proven precedents from the problem's own domain and, mostly, from other domains found by reformulating the question, verifying each tactic with evidence and experts.
Iyengar's precedent search fills the rows of a Choice Map, one per subproblem, with about five tactics each: two non-redundant in-domain best practices and at least three from other domains, so no row is wholly in-domain. Searches start domain-specific, then reformulate the question agnostically (domain removed), partially (one level wider) and in parallel (other domains that fit the agnostic version, each searched). Only past successes count, not failures or current projects, and only the part that drove success is copied. Each tactic needs evidence, a concrete example of it producing a result, and an explanation of why it works from an expert in the tactic's own domain. Teams search individually and pool per row. In her course data, maps with fifteen or more mostly out-of-domain tactics produced ideas peers rated more creative.
Attributes
- Discipline
- Design & Product Practice
- Loss type
- Vestigial
- Goal
- Generate ideas
- Data
- Analytical / expert
- Effort
- Weeks
Steps
- Phrase each subproblem in domain terms and search for in-domain best practices; enter the two strongest.
- Reformulate each subproblem agnostically, partially and in parallel, listing other domains that face the same agnostic problem, and search each.
- Collect a long list of leads and keep only past successes with evidence of a result.
- Verify each tactic's contribution with an expert from that tactic's domain and ask why it works.
- Enter at least three out-of-domain tactics per row with short markers and micro-notes, citing sources and checking patents.
- In teams, search individually, then pool and discuss per row before combining tactics into ideas.
Sources
- Think Bigger (Iyengar, 2023)
Also known as
- In-domain and out-of-domain precedent search
- Search in and out of the box
- Strategic copying
- Choice Map precedent search
- Steal shamelessly
- Analogous inspiration
Categories
- Design
- Design & Product Practice