Points-of-View Skill Documentaries

Description

A skill owner and peers make first-, second- and third-person video documentaries of a skill, and build a prototype that lets someone else experience its essence.

Grounded in the phenomenological view that designers design from a first-person perspective while intermittently taking a third-person one, this five-day exercise makes the shifts explicit. A student documents his own skill on video (first person). He then shows and tells a peer in situ what the skill means to him, and the peer makes his own documentary (second person); the owner uses the peer's film as a mirror to refine his own. Next the owner builds a tool that lets a third person experience the salient element of the skill; that person learns it on video within an hour and makes a reflective documentary. Finally the owner presents all three films and the design and reflects. All perspectives turned out different, and students later took first- and second-person stances more often, for example in interviews.

Attributes

Loss type
Siloed
Stage
Discovery, Design
Effort
Days

Steps

  1. Day 1: the skill owner makes a short video documentary of their own skill from the first-person view.
  2. Day 2: the owner shows and tells a peer in situ what the skill means; the peer makes their own short documentary.
  3. The owner watches the peer's film as a mirror and refines their own film.
  4. Days 3-4: the owner builds a tool or prototype that lets a third person experience the salient element of the skill.
  5. Day 4: a third person learns the new skill on video within about an hour and turns the footage into a reflective documentary.
  6. Day 5: the owner presents the three films and the design side by side and reflects on the differences between perspectives.

Sources

  • HCI Encyclopedia (Soegaard & Dam, 2014)

Also known as

  • First-, second- and third-person perspective documentation
  • Designing for points of view

Categories

  • Design
  • Design & Product Practice