Playability Heuristic Evaluation

Description

An expert inspection of a game against game-specific heuristics covering interface, mechanics, story and play, rather than Nielsen's productivity-software list.

Nielsen's heuristics were written mainly for productivity tools and miss what makes games work, such as pace, challenge, goals, heads-up displays and gameplay. Game-specific sets fill that gap. Federoff's 40 heuristics fall into interface, mechanics and play; HEP has 43 heuristics across play, story, mechanics and usability; Schaffer's 29 cover general, GUI and play. The evaluation follows the usual heuristic method: evaluators play the game individually, note violations, then merge findings with teammates. The book's teaching template records each finding as a row with the heuristic, a severity (for example 'Important'), a description of the problem and an actionable recommendation. Findings then feed research questions for later usability tests and playtests. Chapter 11 shows a variant in which ten generalised heuristics from Desurvire's work are turned into questions that players themselves answer after play, combining inspection with user opinion. The method is cheap and fast, but it reflects the evaluator's judgement, so it complements rather than replaces testing with players.

Attributes

Loss type
Active
Effort
Days

Steps

  1. Choose a game heuristic set (for example Federoff, HEP or Schaffer) suited to the genre and stage.
  2. Have each evaluator play the game independently, focusing on interface, mechanics, story and play.
  3. Record each violation with the heuristic broken, where it occurs and evidence.
  4. Merge findings across evaluators and remove duplicates.
  5. Rate severity and write an actionable recommendation for each issue in a summary table.
  6. Turn the most important issues into research questions for usability tests and playtests.

Sources

  • Garcia-Ruiz, M. (ed.), Games User Research: A Case Study Approach (2016)
  • Drachen, A., Mirza-Babaei, P. & Nacke, L. (eds), Games User Research (2018)

Also known as

  • Game heuristic evaluation
  • Heuristic Evaluation for Playability (HEP)
  • Federoff's game heuristics
  • PLAY heuristics
  • Modular playability heuristics
  • Korhonen playability heuristics
  • Heuristic evaluation of playability
  • Heuristics of Playability
  • PLAY heuristic set
  • Desurvire PLAY

Categories

  • User Research
  • Usability & Evaluation