Piagetian Clinical Interview

Description

Interview a child while they work on a concrete problem, letting each explanation shape the next question, to reveal how they reason rather than whether they are right.

Piaget held that children think differently from adults rather than knowing less. Borrowing from psychiatric interviewing, he replaced fixed question lists with flexible probing: the child works with a concrete task, explains each answer, and the next question follows from that explanation. Wrong answers are the most informative data because they expose the underlying model. A well-known application is the animacy interview, where children say which entities are alive and which can feel, think, grow or move by themselves. Later work showed Piaget overestimated animism because of reliance on verbal justifications, unfamiliar items and the ambiguous word 'alive' (often heard as 'animal'); with simple yes-no property questions and familiar items, preschoolers are broadly accurate. Today this makes the method a direct way to learn how children categorise robots, voice assistants and on-screen agents.

Attributes

Loss type
Unmigrated
Effort
Weeks

Steps

  1. Give the child a concrete task, object or set of familiar entities (animals, plants, artefacts and the target technologies).
  2. Ask what they think will happen, or simple yes-no property questions such as 'can it feel sad?', 'can it think?', 'does it move by itself?'.
  3. Ask the child to explain each answer in their own words, without relying on the justification alone.
  4. Choose the next question from the explanation rather than a fixed list, and try a gentle counter-suggestion to test how firmly the idea is held.
  5. Avoid ambiguous terms like 'alive', or check what the child takes them to mean.
  6. Record answers and explanations verbatim, and code reasoning patterns or attribution profiles by entity and age group.

Sources

  • The Psychology Book (Collin et al., 2012)
  • Wiley-Blackwell Handbook of Childhood Cognitive Development (Goswami, 2011)
  • MIT Psychology (Stangor, 2012)
  • The Development of Language (Gleason & Ratner, 2024)

Also known as

  • Piagetian clinical interview (incl. animacy interviews)
  • Piagetian clinical interview with children
  • Méthode clinique
  • Flexible clinical interview
  • Piaget's critical exploration method
  • Animacy and property-attribution interview with children
  • Animism interview
  • Biological and psychological property attribution

Categories

  • User Research
  • Interviewing & Elicitation