Physicality breakdown audit

Description

Check a hybrid physical-digital device against physical-world rules to judge how users will notice, understand and repair failures.

Physical things show their state, act where and when they are touched, and respond in proportion to effort; digital and hybrid devices often break all three. Usability tests concentrate on first use and success, but long-term usability depends on how breakdowns are detected and repaired, when the tool stops being ready-to-hand and becomes an object of attention. The audit checks each rule in turn, then asks for each break how a user would notice something has gone wrong, what extra visibility repair needs, whether actions can be undone through a natural inverse, and whether irreversible actions are protected. Findings lead to physical or digital put-backs such as indicator lights, displays, haptic kicks, recessed or shaped controls.

Attributes

Loss type
Latent
Effort
Hours

Steps

  1. Take the device and its task in the real context of use.
  2. Check visibility of state, spatial and temporal locality of effect, and proportional response to effort.
  3. For each rule that is broken, ask how a user would detect that something went wrong.
  4. Ask what extra visibility a user needs to repair the problem.
  5. Check reversibility through natural inverse actions, and protection of irreversible actions.
  6. Propose physical or digital put-backs such as lights, displays, haptic feedback, shaping or recessing controls, and test them with breakdown scenarios.

Sources

  • Touch IT (Dix et al., 2022)

Also known as

  • Physicality properties audit for breakdown and repair
  • Designing for failure
  • Physical-world rules audit

Categories

  • Accessibility
  • Human Factors & Error