Description
Replace buttons with direct manipulation by treating data objects as physical things, mapping the verbs they afford to actions, and checking gestures for conflicts and discoverability.
Clark calls buttons a hack: workarounds for when direct interaction is impossible, which add effort and complexity. The practice challenges every button and reimagines data as physical objects, such as a date range as a stretchable band or items as cards to flip, stack or throw aside, then matches verbs to nouns. Borrowing from the real world takes four forms: one-to-one interactions, established notation, physics, and honouring physical constraints; the rule is to import the action, not the object. Abstract and multi-finger gestures are expert shortcuts and always need a visible slow route. Gesture density must be managed: cede gestures to the operating system and browser, prefer edge gestures for system actions, and use radial menus for compact, stable tool sets, which Kurtenbach and Buxton showed users learn to operate by marking.
Attributes
- Discipline
- Design & Product Practice
- Loss type
- Vestigial
- Goal
- Generate ideas
- Stage
- Design
- Data
- Analytical / expert
- Effort
- Days
Steps
- Inventory buttons and controls and ask, for each, whether the content itself could be manipulated directly.
- Name the interface's nouns, list the physical verbs each affords and assign each verb a data meaning.
- Choose a borrowing route for each action: one-to-one interaction, symbols or notation, physics, or physical constraints, borrowing the action rather than the artefact.
- Add abstract or multi-finger gestures only as shortcuts alongside visible controls, and check accessibility for people with limited hand mobility.
- Check conflicts with operating system and browser gestures and between your own gestures; give gestures room and anticipate accidental edge swipes.
- Use radial menus for stable sets of up to about eight items (three or four on phones) and never reorder them dynamically.
- Prototype on the target device and test discoverability with users.
Sources
- Designing for Touch (Clark, 2015)
Also known as
- Physical-metaphor gesture design (information as physical object)
- Content as control
- Noun-verb gesture mapping
- Button challenge
- Gesture conflict check
Categories
- Design
- Design & Product Practice