Persuasive Technology Ethics Assessment

Description

Judge a persuasive product by its intentions, methods and foreseeable outcomes, check targeting of vulnerable groups, and tabulate each stakeholder's gains and losses against stated values.

Fogg notes that interactive persuasion has built-in advantages over users: novelty hides intent, computers borrow a reputation for fairness, they persist without tiring, control which interactions are possible, display emotion without responding to it, and cannot take responsibility. The assessment examines intent; methods, first asking whether the tactic would be ethical if a person used it (deception and coercion always fail; conditioning and surveillance must be overt and supportive); and outcomes, using an intended-by-predictable matrix to assign responsibility to designers, distributors and users. Targeting vulnerable groups is unethical. For hard cases a structured stakeholder analysis lists every party's gains (money, learning, power) and losses (autonomy, privacy, dignity) and weighs the inequities against values written down openly. Because verdicts depend on values, outsiders and affected people should take part.

Attributes

Loss type
Latent
Effort
Days

Steps

  1. State the designers' intent and judge whether it is good, contested or unethical.
  2. List each persuasive method; imagine a human doing the same and judge it, flagging deception, coercion, covert conditioning, punitive surveillance and exploitative emotional appeals.
  3. List intended and reasonably foreseeable unintended outcomes (misuse, overuse, unintended users) and assign responsibility with the intent-by-predictability matrix.
  4. Check whether any vulnerable group (children, older, bereaved or lonely people, employees) is targeted or likely to be reached.
  5. List all stakeholders, including families and communities, and tabulate each one's gains and losses.
  6. Identify who gains most and who loses most, judge the inequities against explicitly written values, and record mitigations.
  7. Revisit after launch and mitigate harms once they become known.

Sources

  • Persuasive Technology (Fogg, 2003)

Also known as

  • Persuasive technology ethics assessment (intentions, methods, outcomes and stakeholder gain-loss analysis)
  • Seven-step stakeholder analysis for ethics
  • Intentions-methods-outcomes analysis
  • Captology ethics review

Categories

  • Research Operations
  • Research Design & Rigor