Persuasive technology analysis

Description

Code each element of a product, or every product in a category, by functional-triad role and influence strategy to map where persuasion comes from and where gaps lie.

Fogg's functional triad classifies how computing products persuade: as tools (making behaviour easier), as media (providing simulated experience) and as social actors (using social cues). The analysis inventories a product's elements and codes each by triad role and by specific strategy: reduction, tunnelling, tailoring, suggestion, self-monitoring, surveillance or conditioning for tools, simulation types for media, and social cues and influence principles for social actors. It distinguishes macrosuasion (persuasion is the product's purpose) from microsuasion (persuasive elements embedded in other products). Applied across a market, it counts strategies per product; a review of 72 mobile health apps found most relied on tracking, analysis or reference material and almost none used social or simulation strategies. Tactics, the implementation of each strategy, are recorded separately, and each element is screened for ethical red flags.

Attributes

Loss type
Vestigial
Effort
Days

Steps

  1. Define the target attitude or behaviour and whether persuasion is the product's main purpose (macro) or embedded (micro).
  2. Inventory user-experience elements: screens, messages, features, notifications, characters.
  3. Code each element by triad role (tool, medium, social actor) and by strategy from the captology list, using a written codebook.
  4. Record the tactic for each strategy (for example how tracking is captured, how often and with what metaphor).
  5. For a category review, apply the same codes to every product with two coders and count strategy frequencies.
  6. Compare strategies used with those suited to the goal and audience, flagging gaps and overused patterns.
  7. Screen each element for ethical red flags: coercion, deception, covert conditioning or surveillance.

Sources

  • Persuasive Technology (Fogg, 2003)
  • MIT Psychology (Stangor, 2012)

Also known as

  • Persuasive technology analysis (functional triad and influence-strategy audit)
  • Captology analysis
  • Functional triad analysis
  • Persuasion strategy content analysis
  • Macrosuasion and microsuasion audit

Categories

  • Analytics & Behaviour
  • Behavioral Science & Economics