Persona-Weighted Feature Prioritisation Matrix

Description

Scores each candidate feature for each persona, typically from -1 to +2, weights scores by persona priority, and ranks features by the weighted sum.

The matrix makes the link from personas to roadmap explicit. Must-have features are set aside; the remaining candidates are rows and each persona is a column, weighted by agreed business importance (for example market size and revenue) with weights summing to 100. Each cell is scored 2 (needed, great value), 1 (useful), 0 (indifferent) or -1 (the persona is confused, annoyed or harmed). Scores ideally come from persona-matched users rating features or allocating a fixed sum of money; when a committee scores, guessed or disputed cells are flagged for later data. Weighted sums are computed and features sorted. Mulder and Yaar's variant starts with directed brainstorming per persona goal against business objectives, rates items 1-5 per persona with the primary persona weighted three times and secondary twice, and adds effort and phase columns. Microsoft's team found it pushed pet features down and made reasoning explicit.

Attributes

Loss type
Vestigial
Effort
Days

Steps

  1. Set aside must-have features and list candidate features as rows; optionally brainstorm features per persona goal against business objectives first.
  2. Add one column per persona with weights summing to 100, based on market size, revenue or strategic priority.
  3. Score each cell 2, 1, 0 or -1, preferably from research with persona-matched users (ratings, surveys or a fixed-budget allocation).
  4. If a committee scores, flag guessed or disputed cells and schedule research to resolve them.
  5. Compute the weighted sum per feature, sort, and add effort and phase columns.
  6. Investigate surprises rather than accepting them, allow argued exceptions for cost, timing or competition, and share the matrix with developers and QA to explain decisions.

Sources

  • Essential Persona Lifecycle (Adlin & Pruitt, 2010)
  • The User Is Always Right (Mulder & Yaar, 2007)
  • Understanding Your Users (1st ed.) (Courage & Baxter, 2005)

Also known as

  • Persona-weighted feature matrix
  • Feature-persona weighted priority matrix
  • Target customer value matrix
  • Persona scope workshop
  • Persona-weighted scope matrix
  • Scope matrix
  • Directed persona brainstorming
  • Persona competitive feature analysis

Categories

  • Analytics & Behaviour
  • Product Analytics & Strategy