Persona Prioritisation by Value and Influence

Description

Rank personas using linked CRM value data and stakeholders' private 100-point allocations, then label each primary, secondary, unimportant or excluded.

Personas are useful only if the team agrees whom to design for when needs conflict. Two complementary procedures do this. Mulder and Yaar link survey respondents to CRM records (spend, transactions, frequency) so each persona has a financial value, then weigh influence on others and reputation; in their brokerage case the feature-hungry segment had the lowest revenue per trade, so another persona was prioritised. Pruitt and Adlin have stakeholders rough-rank persona skeletons, add data on frequency, market size, revenue and strategic importance, and then privately allocate 100 points with no ties except zero. Posted scores expose misalignment, which is discussed until agreed weights emerge. Labels follow: primary (usually one, at most two, wins conflicts), secondary, unimportant and excluded. Priorities can differ by product area.

Attributes

Loss type
Vestigial
Data
Mixed
Effort
Days

Steps

  1. Where possible, link persona survey respondents to CRM data and compute value per persona (for example revenue per transaction or share of spend).
  2. Present persona skeletons with data on frequency of use, market size, revenue and strategic importance, and ask who must be made exceptionally happy.
  3. Have each stakeholder privately allocate 100 points across personas, with no ties except zero.
  4. Post scores in a persona-by-stakeholder grid and discuss discrepancies until agreed weights emerge; allow more than one meeting.
  5. Ask who is missing and add assumption skeletons for any groups not yet represented.
  6. Label each persona primary (one, at most two), secondary, unimportant or excluded, per product area if needed.
  7. Record the weights for use in feature prioritisation matrices.

Sources

  • The User Is Always Right (Mulder & Yaar, 2007)
  • Essential Persona Lifecycle (Adlin & Pruitt, 2010)

Also known as

  • Persona prioritisation
  • Primary, secondary, unimportant and excluded personas
  • Persona financial value analysis
  • Persona skeleton prioritisation with 100-point allocation
  • Stakeholder persona prioritisation

Categories

  • User Research
  • Qualitative Analysis & Synthesis