Perceptual effectiveness review of charts

Description

Judge a chart against perceptual criteria for its message, explain each failure with perception science, and redesign with encodings people read more accurately.

A visualisation succeeds to the degree that people can easily, efficiently, accurately and meaningfully perceive its story. Few's review asks five questions: does the display clearly show how values relate, represent quantities accurately, make comparison easy, make ranked order easy to see, and make obvious how to use the information? Each judgement is backed by a perceptual reason. A 3-D pie with a legend passes only the first: areas, angles and arc lengths are poorly perceived, legends force look-ups and perspective inflates front slices. A ranked, directly labelled bar chart passes all five because position and length on a common baseline are read accurately. Gestalt principles, preattentive attributes and working-memory limits supply the reasons, grounding critique in evidence rather than taste.

Attributes

Loss type
Siloed
Effort
Hours

Steps

  1. Identify the message and the relationship in the data the chart must convey (ranking, part-to-whole, trend, comparison).
  2. State the five criteria: relationship shown, quantities accurate, comparison easy, ranking visible, use obvious.
  3. Judge the display against each criterion as yes, no or partly, giving the perceptual reason.
  4. Check the chart's honesty: an anchored or clearly marked origin, a labelled scale, no area or volume icons that exaggerate differences, absolute values alongside percentages, stated margins of error and a statement of which average is shown.
  5. Redesign using more accurately perceived encodings, such as position and length on a common scale, direct labels and sorted order.
  6. Judge the redesign again, and where stakes are high confirm with a quick task test of reading accuracy.

Sources

  • HCI Encyclopedia (Soegaard & Dam, 2014)
  • A Practical Guide to Designing with Data (Suda, 2010)
  • Statistics (Witte & Witte, 2017)
  • Statistics for Dummies (Rumsey, 2003)

Also known as

  • Perceptual effectiveness review of a data graphic
  • Chart critique against perceptual criteria

Categories

  • Content
  • Information Architecture & Content