Peer Tutoring Evaluation

Description

One child learns a product and then tutors a second child through it; usability problems and mental models are distilled from their dialogue.

Young children struggle with concurrent think-aloud, but they readily explain things to each other. In peer tutoring one child first tries out the product, then becomes tutor to a second child and helps that child use it. The tutor's explanations expose how the product was understood, and the tutee's difficulties expose usability problems, both in natural speech. The method was developed to evaluate a physically interactive computer game. Its validity depends on the role relationship: the tutor must actually tutor and the tutee must accept being taught by a peer. When tutors forget the role the pair behaves like a co-discovery pair, and tutors may take over the task instead of explaining it, so facilitators should brief roles clearly and code dialogue with that in mind.

Attributes

Loss type
Siloed
Stage
Evaluation
Effort
Days

Steps

  1. Recruit pairs of children of similar age and brief the first child that they will later teach a friend.
  2. Let the first child explore and learn the product alone or with light guidance.
  3. Introduce the second child and ask the first to help them use the product, without taking over.
  4. Video-record the session, capturing dialogue and screen or play space.
  5. Code the dialogue for the tutor's explanations (understanding) and the tutee's difficulties (problems).
  6. Note episodes where the tutor took over or the pair drifted into co-discovery, and weigh those data accordingly.

Sources

  • HCI Encyclopedia (Soegaard & Dam, 2014)

Also known as

  • Peer tutoring method

Categories

  • User Research
  • Usability & Evaluation