Participant Map-Making Elicitation

Description

Participants draw or build a map of places, people or devices, and the map anchors an interview about routines, relationships and infrastructure.

A family of generative techniques in which the participant makes a map that then drives the interview. In spatial mapping they draw a known place such as their home and add detail in response to study prompts (router and sockets for setup context, 'where do you feel safest?' for needs), or draw a movement such as a commute. In cognitive mapping the prompt is an activity and the map shows the network of places, devices, websites and transport involved. In social mapping the participant places people on sticky notes nearer or farther by closeness, clusters and names groups, then marks the communication tools used with each with coloured stickers. A tangible variant uses a felt board divided into rooms on which people place appliance tokens and say which they set in advance. Maps do not speak for themselves: they must be interpreted with the participant's explanations.

Attributes

Loss type
Latent
Stage
Discovery
Effort
Weeks

Steps

  1. Choose the starting prompt: a place (spatial map), an activity (cognitive map), the people who matter (social map) or the devices in a home (felt board).
  2. Provide materials: large paper, pens, sticky notes, four or five sticker colours, or a room board with tokens, and record audio or video.
  3. Ask the participant to draw or place items, using a concrete prompt such as 'people you contact once a week or more' and letting them check phones to jog memory.
  4. Have them arrange items by distance, frequency or intimacy, cluster and name groups, and rearrange as they remember more.
  5. Layer prompts tied to the research questions: infrastructure, tools used with each person, devices set in advance, feelings of safety.
  6. Probe concrete recent instances, such as the last contact with a person or the last time a device was configured, in about 45 minutes one-to-one.
  7. Analyse maps only together with interview notes, and compare across participants for recurring patterns.

Sources

  • Designing Connected Products (Rowland et al., 2015)
  • Observing the User Experience (Goodman et al., 2012)
  • Research Methods in HCI (Lazar et al., 2017)

Also known as

  • Participant map-making elicitation (spatial, social and home-technology maps)
  • Participant Map-Making (Spatial and Cognitive Maps)
  • Participant sketch mapping
  • Spatial mapping interview
  • Cognitive mapping (Lanclos)
  • Map-making elicitation
  • Social mapping
  • Social map
  • Relationship map
  • Felt-board home technology mapping
  • Fuzzy felt ethnography
  • Felt board

Categories

  • User Research
  • Interviewing & Elicitation