Old Brain / New Brain Design Audit

Description

Audits a design for how it engages fast, automatic responses (danger, faces, food, novelty) versus deliberative reasoning, ensuring key elements work at both levels.

Susan Weinschenk's 'old brain / new brain' framing, derived from the triune brain model, divides processing into fast, automatic responses to danger, faces, food, novelty and movement, emotional responses, and slow deliberative reasoning. Although the anatomical model is outdated, the practical idea maps onto well-supported dual-process accounts. The audit examines each key screen for what will capture automatic attention, what emotional tone it sets, and whether deliberative content supports the decision once attention is captured. Mismatches, such as decorative imagery outcompeting a critical warning, are flagged. Rigour comes from framing findings in contemporary attention and dual-process terms, avoiding manipulative uses, and validating predictions with eye tracking, first-click or five-second tests.

Attributes

Loss type
Latent
Effort
Hours

Steps

  1. Old-brain filter test for landing pages and critical interfaces:
  2. Show the interface for 50ms (single frame).
  3. (2) Ask: 'What caught your attention?'
  4. Code responses: contrast elements, faces, movement indicators, large text.
  5. (4) Compare to intended attention hierarchy.
  6. (5) Elements that pass the 50ms filter = old-brain salient. Elements that don't = invisible to first-pass attention. Redesign: ensure the most critical element passes the old-brain filter first.

Sources

  • Neuro Web Design — Susan Weinschenk
  • Neuroscience (Bear et al.)
  • Brain & Behaviour (Garrett)
  • Methods Atlas (Gopinath)
  • The Inquiry Series, Ch 9 — Attention — The Gatekeeper

Also known as

  • Three brains audit
  • Neuro web design audit
  • Reptilian brain design

Categories

  • User Research
  • Cognitive Psychology & Perception