Neurophenomenology

Description

Pair trained, detailed first-person descriptions of an experience with time-locked brain or body data, using each to constrain interpretation of the other.

Neurophenomenology rejects treating either brain data or self-report as ground truth. Participants are trained to describe a specific kind of experience precisely, often with micro-phenomenological interviewing. They perform repeated trials while physiological data are recorded, and give a structured report after each trial. Trials are then grouped by experiential category derived from the reports, and the neural data are analysed by those groups; surprising physiological patterns in turn prompt further first-person inquiry. In the standard example, trials sorted by participants' reported readiness revealed distinct brain synchrony patterns that averaged analysis had hidden. A variant alternates scanning an expert practitioner with debriefs, re-instructs, rescans, and tests the resulting distinction in novices. Cautions: an instruction is not the same as performing it, small samples of trained observers limit generality, and physiological signals in applied settings are noisy.

Attributes

Loss type
Unmigrated
Data
Mixed
Effort
Months

Steps

  1. Train participants to describe the target experience precisely, for example with micro-phenomenological interviews.
  2. Run repeated trials of a task while recording time-locked physiological data (EEG, skin conductance, eye tracking).
  3. After each trial, collect a structured first-person report.
  4. Derive experiential categories from the reports and group trials by them.
  5. Analyse the physiological data by those groups, and use unexpected physiological patterns to prompt further first-person inquiry.
  6. With expert participants, alternate recording and debriefing, re-instruct and re-record, then test the resulting distinction in novices.
  7. Report both sides and how each constrained the other.

Sources

  • The Embodied Mind (Varela et al., 2016)
  • Compassion: Bridging Practice and Science (Singer & Bolz, 2013)

Also known as

  • Neurophenomenology: pairing trained first-person reports with neural or physiological data
  • First-person data guided brain analysis
  • Mutual constraints method
  • First-person and third-person bridging with an expert practitioner

Categories

  • Analytics & Behaviour
  • Neuro, Biometrics & Affect