Narrative Usability Test

Description

A one-to-one test in which players work through a prototype of a game's story before it is built, to find confusion, gaps in logic and mismatched expectations.

Narrative usability applies observational usability testing to story rather than interface. Before a narrative is implemented in the game, participants go through a prototype of it from beginning to end (for example scripts, storyboards, animatics or a simple text version) while the researcher observes and asks them to explain what is happening and why. The aim is to reveal areas of confusion, misaligned expectations, interactions with genre conventions and gaps in logic, so writers and designers can either correct the story or deliberately embrace the beliefs players form. Because it happens early, changes are cheap. Medlock notes its main limit: it shows whether the story is understood, not whether players will like it, and gives little data on feelings about the narrative. Outside games, the same approach suits any product that relies on a sequence of explanation, such as onboarding stories, explainer videos, or guided tutorials, where comprehension of the sequence is the question.

Attributes

Loss type
Siloed
Stage
Design
Effort
Days

Steps

  1. Prepare a low-cost prototype of the narrative (script, storyboard, animatic or text) covering the full arc.
  2. Define the key story beats, motivations and facts players must understand.
  3. Run one-to-one sessions in which each participant goes through the prototype in order.
  4. At planned points, ask participants to summarise what has happened, predict what comes next and explain characters' motives.
  5. Note confusions, wrong inferences and genre-based expectations.
  6. Report comprehension problems by beat and agree with writers which to fix and which to keep.

Sources

  • Drachen, A., Mirza-Babaei, P. & Nacke, L. (eds), Games User Research (2018)

Also known as

  • Narrative usability
  • Story comprehension test

Categories

  • User Research
  • Usability & Evaluation