Musical ability screening (Gold-MSI, PROMS, MBEA)

Description

Standardised batteries that profile participants' musical perception and engagement, replacing a binary musician label and flagging congenital amusia, for studies that depend on hearing sound differences.

Studies of audio interfaces often split participants into 'musicians' and 'non-musicians' by training, which misclassifies trained but unmusical people and able but untrained ones. Music psychology offers better tools. PROMS (Profile of Music Perception Skills) and the Gold-MSI (Goldsmiths Musical Sophistication Index) combine perceptual subtests with self-report of engagement and give a profile across domains such as pitch, rhythm and timbre; subtests show domain-specific training effects. The MBEA (Montreal Battery of Evaluation of Amusia), normed on a large sample, identifies the roughly 2-4% of people who are congenitally amusic: they need pitch differences of two or three semitones to notice a change and lose tones held over 3-5 seconds. That matters for any product that codes information in pitch or melody, such as two ringtones distinguishing internal and external calls. The book gives no items or scoring, so use the original instruments.

Attributes

Loss type
Unmigrated
Stage
Evaluation
Effort
Hours

Steps

  1. Identify which auditory abilities the product or study relies on (pitch discrimination, rhythm, timbre, melodic memory).
  2. Choose the matching instrument: Gold-MSI for a quick sophistication index, PROMS for a perceptual profile, MBEA where amusia must be detected.
  3. Administer it before the main study, using the original stimuli and scoring.
  4. Score subtests and keep the profile rather than collapsing to musician versus non-musician.
  5. Stratify or covary results by ability, and flag participants below amusia cut-offs.
  6. Feed findings back into design, for example adding non-pitch cues where amusic users would miss a distinction.

Sources

  • The Science and Psychology of Music (Thompson & Olsen, 2021)

Also known as

  • Musical ability screening of participants
  • Gold-MSI
  • PROMS
  • MBEA
  • Musical sophistication screening
  • Amusia screening

Categories

  • Analytics & Behaviour
  • Survey & Psychometrics