Description
Prototype screen layouts with every letter replaced by 'm' so grouping, alignment and hierarchy can be judged apart from content.
A mumble screen is a layout with its text replaced by strings of the letter m of the same lengths. Removing readable content forces reviewers to judge the screen's structure: whether related items group together, whether alignment and spacing make the hierarchy obvious, and whether the eye lands where it should. Nielsen recommended it under the principle of simple and natural dialogue; the screen can be abstracted further by replacing images and controls with blocks. A second use, from Nygren and colleagues, is as a task analysis probe: show users mumbled versions of forms they know and see whether they can still find or infer information from layout alone. If they can, the new design should preserve those layout cues. Today the idea survives as greyboxing, greeked wireframes and the blur test, usually without the task analysis use.
Attributes
- Discipline
- Design & Product Practice
- Loss type
- Renamed
- Stage
- Design
- Data
- Analytical / expert
- Effort
- Hours
Steps
- Take a screen design and replace all text with 'm' strings of the same length, keeping font sizes and weights.
- Optionally replace images and controls with plain blocks for a further level of abstraction.
- Review grouping, alignment, white space and visual hierarchy, noting where the structure does not show which items belong together.
- Revise the layout and repeat until the intended grouping is visible without content.
- For task analysis, show users mumbled versions of familiar paper or legacy forms and ask them to point to specific information.
- Carry any layout cues users rely on into the new design.
Sources
- Usability Engineering (Nielsen, 1993)
Also known as
- Greeked layout
- Mumble text
Categories
- Design
- Design & Product Practice