Multiphase Mixed Methods Design

Description

Chain several quantitative, qualitative or mixed studies as phases, each feeding materials or findings to the next, under one overarching question that the whole programme answers.

A multiphase design is used when one study cannot answer the question and the research unfolds as a programme. Each phase can itself be convergent, sequential, qualitative or quantitative, but it is planned for what it must hand on: materials, an instrument, a sample or findings that shape the next phase. Rigour comes from stating the overarching question first, drawing a procedural diagram for each phase that lists procedures and products, and writing a method summary that explains how each phase serves the whole. In Haines's dissertation, a convergent survey and interview study produced three versions of a report passage, a qualitative synthesis of 95 articles produced a 39-item rating scale, and a final explanatory sequential experiment had participants rate one randomly assigned passage before focus groups explained the differences. Integration happens across phases, not only within them.

Attributes

Loss type
Siloed
Data
Mixed
Effort
Months

Steps

  1. State the overarching question that the programme as a whole must answer.
  2. Plan the phases and specify what each must produce for the next: materials, an instrument, a sampling frame or findings.
  3. Draw a procedural diagram for each phase listing its procedures and products, and choose its design (for example convergent, exploratory or explanatory sequential).
  4. Run the first phase and convert its results into the inputs needed by later phases.
  5. Run subsequent phases, checking that materials built earlier do not carry confounds (for example differences in length or tone between versions).
  6. Integrate across phases in a method summary and a final interpretation that answers the overarching question.
  7. Report each phase's design, products and limitations so readers can trace how the evidence accumulated.

Sources

  • Value Added by Mixed Methods Research: A Multiphase Mixed Methods Design (Haines, 2011)

Also known as

  • Multiphase design
  • Multi-phase mixed methods programme
  • Multiphase research programme design

Categories

  • Research Operations
  • Research Design & Rigor