Multimodal Opportunity Assessment

Description

A question-led assessment of user needs, context and existing product modes to decide which senses and modalities a product should use and how the change will affect users.

Park and Alderman present this as the starting workflow for any multimodal product, beginning from people rather than technology and extending empathy work to the senses. Designers answer a set of questions about needs: interference and situational or permanent disability, the value of optional modes, whether another sense would feel more natural, whether users must keep focus elsewhere, whether an added modality strengthens perception or memory, human limits technology could cover, personal preferences and whether novelty is appropriate. Context is assessed with contextual inquiry, context-of-use analysis and scenarios extended with multimodal considerations, including non-users who share the environment. The intended change is then classified as adding, augmenting or replacing a mode, or creating a new multimodal product, each with its own cost: augmentation adds cognitive load, replacement demands relearning.

Attributes

Loss type
Latent
Effort
Days

Steps

  1. Work through the needs questions: interference and disability, optional modes, more natural senses, focus elsewhere, strengthened perception, human limits, preferences and novelty.
  2. Assess the context of use: what people perceive and do at the moment of use and what object or activity the product replaces, using contextual inquiry and scenarios.
  3. Include non-users who share the environment and could be affected (bystanders, pedestrians, family members).
  4. Classify the change as adding, augmenting or replacing a mode, or a new multimodal product.
  5. Weigh each change's cost to users, such as added decision load or relearning effort.
  6. Form hypotheses about modalities and explore them with physical prototypes and open-ended trial and error.

Sources

  • Designing Across Senses (Park & Alderman, 2018)

Also known as

  • Sense-led opportunity assessment
  • Workflow to identify multimodal opportunities

Categories

  • Design
  • Design & Product Practice