Description
Present a dilemma in which every option has a cost, ask what should be done and why, and classify the reasoning rather than the choice.
Kohlberg presented 72 boys aged 10 to 16 with dilemmas forcing a choice between two imperfect alternatives, the best known asking whether a man should steal a drug his sick wife needs, and followed many of them every three years for 20 years. From the reasons given, not the choices, he described six stages in three levels: preconventional, conventional and postconventional. The stage scheme has been criticised for gender and cultural bias, notably by Gilligan. For UX the durable core is the elicitation form: a scenario with a real trade-off (privacy against convenience, safety against autonomy) followed by probes on the reasons. This reveals how people weigh competing values better than asking them to rate each value in isolation. Rigour comes from carefully balanced scenarios, consistent probes, and a coding scheme applied by more than one coder.
Attributes
- Discipline
- Interviewing & Elicitation
- Loss type
- Unmigrated
- Stage
- Discovery, Definition
- Data
- Qualitative
- Effort
- Weeks
Steps
- Write three to five short scenarios in which every option carries a real cost to someone.
- Present each scenario and ask what the protagonist should do.
- Probe for reasons: why, what if circumstances changed, who is affected and what would make the other choice acceptable.
- Record answers verbatim.
- Code the reasoning into categories, using Kohlberg's stages or a scheme suited to the topic, with two coders and an agreement check.
- Repeat with the same participants over time if you are studying change in reasoning.
Sources
- The Psychology Book (Collin et al., 2012)
- On Second Thought: Outsmarting Your Mind's Hard-Wired Habits (Herbert, 2010)
- MIT Psychology (Stangor, 2012)
Also known as
- Moral dilemma interview (Kohlberg)
- Dilemma interview
- Heinz dilemma
- Moral judgment interview
Categories
- User Research
- Interviewing & Elicitation