Mood and transient-context check for global self-reports

Description

A design and analysis check that treats global ratings (satisfaction, life quality) as sensitive to transient mood and records or neutralises the conditions that shift it.

When people answer global evaluative questions they consult how they feel and can mistake pre-existing mood for a reaction to the target. In Schwarz and Clore's telephone interviews, life satisfaction was higher on sunny days, but asking about the weather as an aside removed the difference while current mood reports were unchanged: once a transient cause is salient, people discount it. Happy moods also favour heuristic processing and sad moods detailed processing. For surveys this means global ratings collected after an emotionally loaded task, during an outage, or under notable external conditions carry mood that is not about the product. The check is to record those conditions, randomise the timing of global items, compare across conditions and, where appropriate, make the transient cause salient. Feelings genuinely caused by the product are valid data, so the aim is attribution, not removal.

Attributes

Loss type
Latent
Effort
Days

Steps

  1. Identify global ratings collected after emotionally loaded tasks, failures, or under notable conditions (outages, weather, news events, time pressure).
  2. Record those conditions alongside each response, or randomise whether global questions come before or after the loaded task.
  3. Compare global ratings across conditions to estimate mood carry-over.
  4. Where appropriate, make the transient cause salient (for example a brief aside about a known outage) so respondents can discount it.
  5. Interpret and report global ratings with the mood context stated, separating product-caused from incidental affect.

Sources

  • Heuristics and Biases (Gilovich et al., 2002)

Also known as

  • Feelings-as-information check
  • Mood misattribution check

Categories

  • Analytics & Behaviour
  • Survey & Psychometrics