Modular Interface Evaluation (Fodor's Criteria)

Description

Evaluates which interface responses rely on fast, automatic, encapsulated perceptual processes versus slow central reasoning, designing critical signals for the former.

Fodor argued that input systems such as vision and language parsing are modular: domain-specific, mandatory, fast, informationally encapsulated (unaffected by beliefs) and shallow in output, in contrast to slow, flexible central reasoning. Modular interface evaluation applies these criteria to interface signals, asking which information users must process quickly and reliably and whether it is presented in forms that engage modular perception (distinct colour, motion, sound, spatial position) or forms that require central interpretation (codes, text, calculation). Signals critical under time pressure should exploit modular processing; information requiring judgement can rely on central processes. Rigour comes from a systematic signal inventory, grounding in perception research, and confirming classifications with reaction-time or detection measures.

Attributes

Loss type
Extinct
Effort
Days

Steps

  1. Module quality audit for design systems: for each interface component, evaluate:
  2. Domain-specificity (does it do exactly one thing?),
  3. Mandatory operation (does it always behave consistently?),
  4. Informational encapsulation (does it work without depending on external state?),
  5. Graceful failure modes (when it fails, does it fail predictably?). Score each criterion 0–2. Components scoring < 6/8 are architectural debt.

Sources

  • The Modularity of the Mind — Jerry Fodor

Also known as

  • Modularity analysis
  • Encapsulation analysis

Categories

  • User Research
  • Cognitive Psychology & Perception