Mock-up and Trial Sessions (Cooperative Prototyping)

Description

Users try out tangible mock-ups and early prototypes in simulated work situations, modifying them with designers on the spot.

In the UTOPIA project with Nordic graphic workers, designers built mock-ups of page-layout systems from cardboard, paper and slides so typographers could experience and evaluate future technology in realistic work situations. The treatise lists mock-up and trial sessions among the core Scandinavian methods. Cooperative prototyping (Bødker and Grønbæk) extended this with computer prototypes modified during sessions. The rigour lies in grounding evaluation in simulated real work, letting users' tacit skills surface through use rather than description, and treating the mock-up as a shared language rather than a test object. Unlike usability testing, users co-author changes.

Attributes

Loss type
Siloed
Stage
Design
Effort
Weeks

Steps

  1. Build a mock-up or modifiable prototype representing the future system in its work setting.
  2. Prepare realistic work scenarios drawn from current practice.
  3. Have users enact the scenarios with the mock-up, thinking aloud and improvising.
  4. Pause to discuss breakdowns and modify the mock-up together on the spot.
  5. Record changes and the reasons users gave for them.
  6. Iterate across sessions, gradually increasing fidelity.

Sources

  • Lost Methods in UX — A Complete Treatise (Gopinath)
  • Ehn P & Kyng M (1991) Cardboard computers: mocking-it-up or hands-on the future. In Design at Work
  • Bødker S & Grønbæk K (1991) Cooperative prototyping. IJMMS 34(3)

Also known as

  • Cooperative prototyping
  • UTOPIA mock-ups
  • Hands-on mock-ups

Categories

  • Design
  • Participatory, Design & Futures