Mixed Methods Grounded Theory (MM-GT)

Description

Build or test a context-specific theory by running grounded theory's constant comparison and theoretical sampling across both qualitative and quantitative data.

Mixed methods grounded theory treats grounded theory and quantitative analysis as one integrated methodology rather than two studies stapled together. Planning uses a mixing template: for each level (paradigm, framework, assumptions, design, data, analysis, reporting) the researcher records what each method contributes and where they reinforce each other, for example abductive theoretical sampling. Two designs are common. In the linked-strands design the qualitative and quantitative strands stay separate, and an abductive loop is triggered whenever their results conflict. In the embedded design, constant comparison is applied to qualitative and quantitative material as a single dataset. Rigour comes from naming the grounded theory variant and the mixed design explicitly, showing theoretical sampling, saturation and memoing, and producing an actual theory model rather than a list of themes. Reviews find many published MM-GT studies generate little theory; building theory qualitatively and then testing it quantitatively is recommended but under-used.

Attributes

Loss type
Siloed
Data
Mixed
Effort
Months

Steps

  1. State the purpose and fill the mixing template at planning, recording each method's contribution at the levels of paradigm, design, data, analysis and reporting.
  2. Choose between separate linked strands and an embedded design in which constant comparison runs over both data types.
  3. Code the qualitative data (initial, focused, theoretical codes) and analyse the quantitative data, sampling theoretically between exploring and checking.
  4. Where the strands disagree, generate new explanations abductively and return to both datasets to test them.
  5. Build an integrated visual model of the emerging theory, showing which evidence supports each relation.
  6. Report against grounded theory criteria (theoretical sampling, saturation, memoing, theory produced) and mixed methods criteria (named design, integration, procedural diagram, legitimation).

Sources

  • The Sage Handbook of Mixed Methods Research Design (Poth, 2023)

Also known as

  • Mixed grounded theory
  • Mixed-design grounded theory

Categories

  • User Research
  • Qualitative Analysis & Synthesis