Description
Add a secondary qualitative strand before, during or after an experiment so participants' experiences shape its design, explain its process or interpret its outcomes.
A complex design in which a core mixed methods design is embedded as a supportive strand inside a primary experiment or trial, written QUAN(qual). Qualitative data can enter before the experiment (an embedded exploratory sequential design, to shape recruitment, procedures or the intervention), during it (an embedded convergent design, capturing participants' experience alongside pre and post measures), or after it (an embedded explanatory sequential design, to explain outcomes). The connection points are the integration points and should be drawn on a procedural diagram. Creswell's earlier concurrent embedded strategy, from which this grew, also covers the multilevel variant, in which different methods are used at different organisational levels. Rigour requires a sound experiment first, an explicit reason for each qualitative component, and integration at stated points rather than an afterthought. Weaknesses include unequal evidence between strands and discrepancies that need resolving.
Attributes
- Discipline
- Research Design & Rigor
- Loss type
- Latent
- Stage
- Evaluation, Post-launch
- Data
- Mixed
- Effort
- Weeks
Steps
- Design a rigorous experiment or trial as the primary study, with outcomes and analysis fixed in advance.
- State explicitly why qualitative data are being added (shape the intervention, understand process, explain results).
- Choose the entry points: before (exploratory), during (convergent) and/or after (explanatory) the experiment.
- Collect qualitative data at one or several time points as resources allow, without contaminating the experimental conditions.
- Analyse each strand separately, then integrate at the stated points: adjust procedures, compare in-trial experience with measured outcomes, or explain results.
- Draw a procedural diagram showing the experiment, qualitative boxes and integration points in QUAN(qual) notation.
Sources
- Research Design (5th ed.) (Creswell & Creswell, 2018)
- Research Design (3rd ed.) (Creswell, 2009)
Also known as
- Embedded experimental mixed methods design
- Mixed methods intervention design
- Qualitative data embedded in a trial
- Concurrent embedded strategy
- Multilevel mixed design
Categories
- Research Operations
- Research Design & Rigor