Mixed Methods Evaluation and Scaffolded Intervention Design

Description

Develop, implement and evaluate a complex intervention in phases, using mixed methods at each phase and a convergent process evaluation alongside the outcome trial.

A phased programme design rather than a single study. Creswell's mixed methods evaluation design places core designs along the evaluation sequence, from needs assessment through programme development and process evaluation to outcome evaluation. Fetters' scaffolded design, combined with the MRC framework for complex interventions, makes this concrete. Development collects site context and feasibility data and builds the intervention on an explicit theory, refined in iterative pilots. Implementation uses train-the-trainer cascades, structured communication between central and local teams, monitoring against standard procedures and an implementation matrix recording how sites vary. Evaluation runs an outcome trial and, alongside it, a convergent process evaluation of fidelity, delivery, reach, receipt and context, merged in joint displays. Its rigour lies in linking each phase's findings to the next and in separating failure of the idea from failure of delivery.

Attributes

Loss type
Siloed
Data
Mixed
Effort
Months

Steps

  1. Needs assessment and development: collect site context with information sheets, interviews and feasibility questionnaires.
  2. Build the intervention on a stated programme theory and refine it through iterative pilots.
  3. Implementation: set up train-the-trainer cascades, structured central-local communication and monitoring against standard procedures.
  4. Record site variation in an implementation matrix (what was adapted, where and why).
  5. Evaluation: run the outcome trial with pre-specified outcomes.
  6. Run a convergent process evaluation of fidelity, delivery, reach, receipt and context, and merge it with outcomes in joint displays.

Sources

  • The Sage Handbook of Mixed Methods Research Design (Poth, 2023)
  • Research Design (5th ed.) (Creswell & Creswell, 2018)

Also known as

  • Scaffolded mixed methods intervention design
  • Scaffolded design
  • Mixed methods evaluation design

Categories

  • Research Operations
  • Research Design & Rigor