Description
Plan each prototype by setting fidelity separately on five dimensions to suit the assumption tested or the audience addressed, instead of choosing one overall low, mid or high level.
McElroy warns that too high a fidelity makes people comment on polish while too low leaves them without context. Following McCurdy and colleagues, she splits fidelity into five independent dimensions: visual refinement, breadth of functionality, depth of functionality, interactivity and data model. Each prototype goal is run through the dimensions to give a mixed-fidelity specification, for example low visual refinement with high depth to test one task in detail, with realistic data so that extremes such as very long titles appear. For communication rather than testing, she plans around one named audience and one decision: rough artefacts for designers, mid or mixed fidelity for stakeholders, specifications for developers, and polished non-functional pieces with rougher working ones for investors, presented as a user scenario with an explicit ask.
Attributes
- Discipline
- Design & Product Practice
- Loss type
- Latent
- Stage
- Design, Evaluation
- Data
- Analytical / expert
- Effort
- Days
Steps
- State the prototype's goal: the assumption to test, or the one audience and the decision or reaction you want from them.
- Decide what content and interactions are needed for that goal.
- For each of the five dimensions (visual refinement, breadth, depth, interactivity, data model), decide whether it must be low, medium or high, keeping every dimension that does not serve the goal as low as possible.
- Use real or realistic data wherever the data model matters, including extreme cases.
- Build to that specification; when presenting, frame it as a scenario of a named user and say up front what feedback is wanted.
- Check during testing or review whether low dimensions distracted people, and record feedback.
- Raise fidelity on further dimensions in later iterations as assumptions are settled.
Sources
- Prototyping for Designers (McElroy, 2016)
Also known as
- Mixed-fidelity prototype specification (five dimensions of fidelity)
- Five dimensions of fidelity
- Mixed-fidelity prototyping
- Fidelity dimension matrix
- Audience-centric prototyping for communication
- Prototyping to communicate
- Stakeholder prototype presentation
Categories
- Design
- Design & Product Practice