Mindfulness-based first-person inquiry

Description

A disciplined first-person method in which a trained observer notices, labels and slows down experience to describe feeling tone, intention and attention shifts without judgement.

Varela, Thompson and Rosch argued that cognitive science lacked a disciplined way of examining experience, and proposed mindfulness/awareness practice as one. The observer anchors attention (on the breath or a routine action), notices each departure without judgement and returns, labels mental events by type ('thinking', 'planning') rather than following their content, and slows actions to catch the intention before movement. Category lists such as feeling tone (pleasant, unpleasant, neutral) serve as prompts, not a coding scheme. The authors contrasted this with Wundt-style introspection, which imposed theory-given elements. The revised edition qualifies the method: observation alters experience, and the original framing is now described as naive. For UX the transferable elements are researcher self-training in non-judgemental noticing, typed labelling of experience, and slowed action to reveal micro-intentions, with findings treated as provisional.

Attributes

Loss type
Siloed
Stage
Discovery
Effort
Weeks

Steps

  1. Choose a simple anchor for attention, such as the breath or a routine product action.
  2. Attend to it; each time attention wanders, notice this without judgement and return.
  3. When a mental event arises, label its type briefly ('thinking', 'feeling', 'planning') instead of following its content.
  4. For a chosen moment, ask how it arose, under what conditions, what the reaction was and where the sense of 'I' occurred.
  5. Slow a routine action right down to notice the intention and feeling tone before each movement.
  6. Use a category list (feeling tone, impulse towards or away, intention, attention) as prompts, not as a fixed coding scheme.
  7. Record observations soon afterwards and compare them with others' reports or with third-person data.

Sources

  • The Embodied Mind (Varela et al., 2016)

Also known as

  • Mindfulness/awareness-based first-person inquiry
  • Contemplative first-person method
  • Mindful open-ended reflection
  • Shamatha-vipashyana as a method of examining experience
  • Mental noting

Categories

  • User Research
  • Cognitive Psychology & Perception