Miles and Huberman Analytic Displays

Description

A three-part analytic system of data reduction, structured data displays (matrices, networks) and explicit conclusion verification for systematic applied qualitative analysis.

Miles and Huberman argued that qualitative analysis fails mostly because researchers keep data as unbroken text that cannot be overviewed. Their framework has three concurrent components: data reduction (memoing, coding, pattern noting), data display (case-ordered meta-matrices, conceptually ordered displays, time-ordered matrices, causal networks) and conclusion drawing with verification (negative cases, rival explanations, member checks, comparing cases where a finding should and should not appear). Displays are the analytic engine: rows of cases against columns of themes reveal within-case and cross-case patterns simultaneously. Their sourcebook catalogues dozens of display types with tactics for generating and testing meaning, making qualitative inference explicit, replicable and auditable.

Attributes

Loss type
Siloed
Stage
Definition
Effort
Weeks

Steps

  1. Write analytic memos and develop a start list of codes from your research questions, then code the data and note emerging patterns.
  2. Choose a display suited to the question: a case-ordered meta-matrix for cross-participant comparison, a time-ordered matrix for change, or a causal network for explanation.
  3. Populate cells with condensed summaries and short quotes, keeping a decision rule for what goes into each cell so displays are reproducible.
  4. Read across rows and down columns to note patterns, contrasts, clusters and outliers; record each tentative conclusion as a memo.
  5. Verify each conclusion using negative cases, rival explanations, checks with participants and comparison of cases where the finding should and should not hold.
  6. Report the displays alongside conclusions so readers can see the evidence behind every claim.

Sources

  • Qualitative Data Analysis (Miles & Huberman) via Sage Handbook
  • Cambridge Handbook of Research Methods
  • Qualitative Data Analysis: An Expanded Sourcebook (Miles & Huberman)
  • The Inquiry Series, Vol II, Ch 29
  • Miles, M. & Huberman, A. M., Qualitative Data Analysis: An Expanded Sourcebook, 2nd ed. (1994)

Also known as

  • Matrix and network displays
  • Data reduction-display-verification
  • Qualitative Data Analysis (Miles & Huberman)
  • Qualitative data analysis sourcebook methods
  • AQDA
  • Matrices and networks
  • Cross-case displays
  • Miles and Huberman Data Display Analysis

Categories

  • User Research
  • Qualitative Analysis & Synthesis